| Author |
Message |
KGT
Guest
|
Posted:
Wed Nov 09, 2005 8:15 pm Post subject:
Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
I would post this on music.makers.band but they no longer seem to
define bands as live performing groups with live audio issues. They
seem more about playing each others new Hip Hop MP3 s etc.
I thought in my 30 yrs I'd seen most everything strange a local
Musician can do, this caught me by surprise. I play keys, mostly
piano/organ, in Blues/Rock so I'm usually struggling to be heard even
with my 400W JBL EON G2. Last nite's audition in a basement practice
room ~15X18 6.5ceilings I started the first tune and "Boom- Boom" the
economy JBL 15+1 on a stick next to my head was pumping copious kick!
To make it worse the drummer had poor meter and kept speeding up. I
couldn't hear the bassist 8 ft away or myself just some guitar and
BAM BAM! After the first song, some Stevie Ray beat to death tune, I
asked why the kick was mic'd & so loud. Drummer said "I tune it so dead
you can't hear it without PA help!" He did turn it down to just
marginal ear bleed level to his credit.
These guys were my age (old as dirt) and quite experienced so they had
no excuse. Why do some bands still insist on rehearsing at near stage
levels? I've learned and become accustomed to very moderate levels with
minimal gear that doesn't have to replicate every last note and Watt
and box from the live rig.
Kevin T
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Skeeter
Guest
|
Posted:
Wed Nov 09, 2005 10:47 pm Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
Hi Kevin,
Get away from these clowns. What kind of "audition" is this? Run one
of those cheap JBL mains right next to the drummer's head so you can
turn the sound down and he can hear himself. It sounds like a bunch of
middle aged "wanna be's" that don't really perform as a business. It
sounds like they are getting their jollies by blowing each others heads
off in a buddie's basement rather than perparing for a perfomance.
You are absolutely correct in that a rehearsal or practice should be
run at the lowest levels possible to be able to hear everything that
may need help from rearranging, or playing technique. Turning up the
levels in a rehearsal just masks any deficiencies by "steamrolling"
everything with a wall of sound. Great for a rush, but that's about
it.
If a performer or group can sound great at a low volume, it will always
sound fantastic when it is time to "turn it up." If these mature,
experienced performers will not wise up and grow up, get the hell out
of there.
All the best to you,
Skeeter. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Tim Scott
Guest
|
Posted:
Thu Nov 10, 2005 12:47 am Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
"Skeeter" <harpmeister@sympatico.ca> wrote in message
news:1131554846.906216.114520@g47g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
| Quote: | Hi Kevin,
Get away from these clowns. What kind of "audition" is this? Run one
of those cheap JBL mains right next to the drummer's head so you can
turn the sound down and he can hear himself. It sounds like a bunch of
middle aged "wanna be's" that don't really perform as a business. It
sounds like they are getting their jollies by blowing each others heads
off in a buddie's basement rather than perparing for a perfomance.
You are absolutely correct in that a rehearsal or practice should be
run at the lowest levels possible to be able to hear everything that
may need help from rearranging, or playing technique. Turning up the
levels in a rehearsal just masks any deficiencies by "steamrolling"
everything with a wall of sound. Great for a rush, but that's about
it.
If a performer or group can sound great at a low volume, it will always
sound fantastic when it is time to "turn it up." If these mature,
experienced performers will not wise up and grow up, get the hell out
of there.
|
Learn to play quietly - full stop.
If you can play quiet in your rehearsals, then also play quietly in your
actual gig, and then the FOH engineer will have a chance of getting a good
sound for your audience.
Your ears will last longer.
You'll be able to hear better what is going on on stage.
You'll find singing in tune easier too. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Skeeter
Guest
|
Posted:
Thu Nov 10, 2005 2:20 am Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
Hi Tim,
Fair comment and good advice. From the description of the "audition"
that Kevin provided, I doubt very much that there will be a FOH
engineer present at an engagement with this group. Maybe I'm wrong, it
wouldn't be the first time. The scene described just has the feeling
of a group of poorly prepared guys playing for beer money at the local
pub. I hope that my premonitions regarding this are wrong.
Cheers,
Skeeter |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Phildo
Guest
|
Posted:
Thu Nov 10, 2005 2:24 am Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
"Tim Scott" <timscott18@nospamplease.spamarrest.com> wrote in message
news:3tf2dbFsj9iiU1@individual.net...
| Quote: | Learn to play quietly - full stop.
|
Actually Tim, re-read the OP and you will see he already has and is merely
complaining about the clowns he auditioned with who couldn't.
| Quote: | If you can play quiet in your rehearsals, then also play quietly in your
actual gig, and then the FOH engineer will have a chance of getting a good
sound for your audience.
Your ears will last longer.
You'll be able to hear better what is going on on stage.
You'll find singing in tune easier too.
|
Good advice that should be given to all musos the minute they pick up an
instrument.
Phildo |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
KGT
Guest
|
Posted:
Thu Nov 10, 2005 3:13 am Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
Skeeter
You nailed it and thats my life. Playing weekends for $50-$100 in pubs
is about the only thrill I get at this late stage of life. I have a
good corporate audio job at Motorola but not much time/energy after
that. So weekend warrior is the best I can do. And yes very few gigs
around here come with (or can afford) a soundman so my sound skills
come in handy.
Kevin Tracy |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Tim Scott
Guest
|
Posted:
Thu Nov 10, 2005 3:28 am Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
"Phildo" <Phil@phildo.net> wrote in message
news:3tf476Fsbq7bU1@individual.net...
| Quote: |
"Tim Scott" <timscott18@nospamplease.spamarrest.com> wrote in message
news:3tf2dbFsj9iiU1@individual.net...
Learn to play quietly - full stop.
Actually Tim, re-read the OP and you will see he already has and is merely
complaining about the clowns he auditioned with who couldn't.
If you can play quiet in your rehearsals, then also play quietly in your
actual gig, and then the FOH engineer will have a chance of getting a
good sound for your audience.
Your ears will last longer.
You'll be able to hear better what is going on on stage.
You'll find singing in tune easier too.
Good advice that should be given to all musos the minute they pick up an
instrument.
|
Yeah, wasn't too clear - was aiming the 'play quietly' comment at the band
as a whole rather than the individual who posted. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Geoff@work
Guest
|
Posted:
Thu Nov 10, 2005 5:14 am Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
"Tim Scott" <timscott18@nospamplease.spamarrest.com> wrote in message
| Quote: |
Learn to play quietly - full stop.
If you can play quiet in your rehearsals, then also play quietly in your
actual gig, and then the FOH engineer will have a chance of getting a good
sound for your audience.
Your ears will last longer.
You'll be able to hear better what is going on on stage.
You'll find singing in tune easier too.
|
A lot of bands use excess volume 'because it gets our sound better'. Often
they are using brute force to compensate for other deficiencies, as the
mistakes disappear into the cacophony.
geoff |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Rob Beech
Guest
|
Posted:
Thu Nov 10, 2005 5:31 am Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
"KGT" <kgtracy@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1131545733.229362.159190@g44g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
| Quote: | I would post this on music.makers.band but they no longer seem to
define bands as live performing groups with live audio issues. They
seem more about playing each others new Hip Hop MP3 s etc.
I thought in my 30 yrs I'd seen most everything strange a local
Musician can do, this caught me by surprise. I play keys, mostly
piano/organ, in Blues/Rock so I'm usually struggling to be heard even
with my 400W JBL EON G2. Last nite's audition in a basement practice
room ~15X18 6.5ceilings I started the first tune and "Boom- Boom" the
economy JBL 15+1 on a stick next to my head was pumping copious kick!
To make it worse the drummer had poor meter and kept speeding up. I
couldn't hear the bassist 8 ft away or myself just some guitar and
BAM BAM! After the first song, some Stevie Ray beat to death tune, I
asked why the kick was mic'd & so loud. Drummer said "I tune it so dead
you can't hear it without PA help!" He did turn it down to just
marginal ear bleed level to his credit.
These guys were my age (old as dirt) and quite experienced so they had
no excuse. Why do some bands still insist on rehearsing at near stage
levels? I've learned and become accustomed to very moderate levels with
minimal gear that doesn't have to replicate every last note and Watt
and box from the live rig.
Kevin T
|
Whilst it probasbly wont help you with your current setup.. A band i work
with at FOH for 95% of gigs they do use IEM's on stage.
When they reherse they dont take amps. or a pa. they quite simply use the
IEM rig. they use an old mx3242x 16 channel deks of mine for this purpose.
plug guitars bass and keys straight into the desk. the drums create enough
noise to have an ambient mic round them. then they each have a vocal mic.
the drummer plays with pads on which keeps the room noise to a minimum
(theres no reason why they need to they just do). its something that before
this i never really considered but it seems to work for them.
As i sai i'm not suggesting you go and buy an IEM rig and do this. just
showing everyone a few ideas and how some bands rehearse.
Rob |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Skeeter
Guest
|
Posted:
Thu Nov 10, 2005 5:42 am Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
Hi Kevin,
Sorry if I may have seemed a bit condescending in my description of
your situation. No offence intended. Playing for weekend thrills and
a bit of beer money can still be fun. But you seriously have to get
these guys under control if you want to have fun. Playing with people
who don't have the desire to get the music done right can be a painful
experience.
Have a meeting with them. Put a beer in everyone's hand and have a few
munchies to keep them with you for 15 minutes. Explain how much more
fun performing will be if everyone plays it as a team, and that
rehearsals need to be used to work out any issues and polish the act.
Practicing at low SPL is essential to understanding exactly how well
everyone is performing. If they won't agree to commit to a little
sanity, get looking for another group.
Best of luck Kevin,
Skeeter. |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Ron Capik
Guest
|
Posted:
Thu Nov 10, 2005 5:42 am Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
KGT wrote:
| Quote: | Skeeter
You nailed it and thats my life. Playing weekends for $50-$100 in pubs
is about the only thrill I get at this late stage of life. I have a
good corporate audio job at Motorola but not much time/energy after
that. So weekend warrior is the best I can do. And yes very few gigs
around here come with (or can afford) a soundman so my sound skills
come in handy.
Kevin Tracy
|
Though not stated [but implied] Kevin is an experienced FOH guy.
Seems his mates don't share his experience or views.
Kevin, best of luck in educating your band mates.
I think my "live sound for gigging musicians" class may have had
a positive impact on a few weekend warriors.
Yours may be an up hill battle. Do what you can to educate,
else: " ~protect your ears~ !"
Later...
Ron Capik
-- |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
Ron Cole
Guest
|
Posted:
Thu Nov 10, 2005 10:20 pm Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
Hi Kevin
I've been there as well, now the group I'm with now is a way more sensible
when it comes to levels, and to take it a step further, we rehearse 100%
under headphones, using a Behringer 8 channel headphone amp. The drums are
mic'ed, and we run the board in a stereo mode , the headphone mix is a total
combination of all instruments and singers, so to get a good sound we play
to the mix, and to be honest we've gotten a whole lot better for it.
Harmonies , guitar solo's , you name it , they've all improved. So if you
where to walk by the rehearsal location all you'd hear are the drums and the
odd singer, this also allows us to practice without the neighbors
complaining .... best move I've made , so easy on my ears !!
Hope this helps.
"KGT" <kgtracy@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1131545733.229362.159190@g44g2000cwa.googlegroups.com...
| Quote: | I would post this on music.makers.band but they no longer seem to
define bands as live performing groups with live audio issues. They
seem more about playing each others new Hip Hop MP3 s etc.
I thought in my 30 yrs I'd seen most everything strange a local
Musician can do, this caught me by surprise. I play keys, mostly
piano/organ, in Blues/Rock so I'm usually struggling to be heard even
with my 400W JBL EON G2. Last nite's audition in a basement practice
room ~15X18 6.5ceilings I started the first tune and "Boom- Boom" the
economy JBL 15+1 on a stick next to my head was pumping copious kick!
To make it worse the drummer had poor meter and kept speeding up. I
couldn't hear the bassist 8 ft away or myself just some guitar and
BAM BAM! After the first song, some Stevie Ray beat to death tune, I
asked why the kick was mic'd & so loud. Drummer said "I tune it so dead
you can't hear it without PA help!" He did turn it down to just
marginal ear bleed level to his credit.
These guys were my age (old as dirt) and quite experienced so they had
no excuse. Why do some bands still insist on rehearsing at near stage
levels? I've learned and become accustomed to very moderate levels with
minimal gear that doesn't have to replicate every last note and Watt
and box from the live rig.
Kevin T
|
|
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
John O
Guest
|
Posted:
Thu Nov 10, 2005 11:56 pm Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
| Quote: | we rehearse 100%
under headphones, using a Behringer 8 channel headphone amp.
|
The obvious question is...why not play your gigs this way? :-)
-John O |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
KGT
Guest
|
Posted:
Fri Nov 11, 2005 12:34 am Post subject:
Re: Loud rehersals (Kick Mic) |
|
|
Thank everyone
Good ideas some more practical & affordable than others. Good news, I
solved the audition bands problem. I told them its too far (and it was)
to drive weekly. I did tell the guitarist ( My friend who begged me to
audition) the truth about "BAM BAM" and my minimalist approch. We're
still friends and they're still looking for keys :)
Thanks
Kevin T |
|
| Back to top |
|
 |
|
|
|
|